Which app do I use?

2100
11
12-01-2016 07:01 AM
AdrianWelsh
MVP Honored Contributor

Hi,

I have a land surveyor who will be going into the field and will need to use a mobile app on his phone. My question for the GeoNet is, which app would be best to use?

Here is what we need. The needs to be able to:

  • use GPS (on smart phone)
  • consume and display ArcGIS Online services
  • show a basemap
  • show an icon of where the GPS currently is and have the icon update when the GPS (person) moves

It would be nice if the app were:

  • to be able to record points and/or map notes
  • free (ish)

We have an ArcGIS Online Organizational account. Do any of you expert GeoNeters have any great ideas on which online app is best? I know there is a wide selection including (but not limited to):

https://community.esri.com/groups/survey123?sr=search&searchId=b6618de8-2c62-480a-9f7e-e74acc98f6d3&...https://community.esri.com/community/gis/applications/collector-for-arcgis?sr=search&searchId=8ff49f...https://community.esri.com/groups/navigator?sr=search&searchId=121724ea-b50a-4f28-ac30-87fe48005d9d&...https://community.esri.com/groups/workforce-for-arcgis?sr=search&searchId=121724ea-b50a-4f28-ac30-87...‌ GeoForms, https://community.esri.com/community/gis/applications/operations-dashboard-for-arcgis?sr=search&sear...https://community.esri.com/groups/mobile-gis?sr=search&searchId=f3b13fc2-e209-4e23-934c-d3058c01292f...https://community.esri.com/groups/appstudio?sr=search&searchId=ebc3530a-f68c-4a8d-92c6-6d6af106ab04&...

Thanks!

Adrian

0 Kudos
11 Replies
AdrianWelsh
MVP Honored Contributor

Thanks Mitch.

Those are some good options. Though, I too have had lots of issues with collector on my Android device - particularly in terms of offline mapping and the syncing afterwards. Basically it would never sync and just lose the data. It even got lost after digging into the phone and pulling out the .geodatabase file, so I basically gave up on it (plus I received negative news from an Esri employee at the User Conference about it which soured me more - however, from speaking with other Esri employees, this employee was in the minority on his opinions).

In any case, we do not have an enterprise geodatabase unfortunately so these options would not work as smoothly. Thanks again for your help.

ShelbySouthworth
New Contributor III

That is exactly my problem. Having worked with ESRI software for almost a decade at this point, I was privileged enough to go to school and work in places with a full suit of Enterprise capabilities (as large organizations). Now I find that I have to MacGyver/ hodge-podge almost half of the work I do at my current job because I can't by default do certain things with ESRI; I find myself having to go to open source software, or more recently, start venturing into the Developers world just to see what I can do with my Python/Java/JavaScript know-how to get our projects off the ground. Which is a great step, thoroughly interesting, and I would encourage anyone to look into .... but like most people I don't have the luxury of spending my days at work learning code and how to apply it because there is 10 years worth of GIS work to do sitting in the company vault that is entirely my responsibility. Which means I have to do it at night. I don't have a family or kids so after hours works okay, but now I'm putting in 60 hrs a week just on my career. Just for the chance of finding a better way

I know its a privilege you pay for but it strikes me that even outside of packages you can purchase to augment your license, or access to mobile capabilities that are included, there are simply things that will only work/ work better with, or problems that only have reasonable solutions through/ or ultimately end up requiring access to, Enterprise.

0 Kudos