ArcGIS online vs Server

3581
1
01-16-2018 09:48 AM
KB1
by
New Contributor II

Hello,

I was hoping to get a clearer understanding as the approach other organizations have taken and what they have found when moving to the ESRI suite.  

Given budget challenges and constraints, we have taken the approach of using ArcGIS Online to augment our current GIS shortcomings and thus far its been quite successful.  In years past we had reviewed the ArcGIS options but the online component had not yet matured to the degree it is now and so we waited.

Now, we are looking to expand into using ArcGIS further, and keeping the budget challenges at the forefront it's important that we find a solution that meets our organizations needs moving forward but keeping the budget impacts at a minimum.  

Given that many software companies have moved towards the SAAS and PAAS approaches, (no different than ESRI) does it make sense to move to the ArcServer or have others found that the ability to customize ArcGIS Online and the tools offered closed the gap between the two platforms enough that introducing ArcServer is not as necessary as has been in the past?

I would like to hear other opinions on the subject.

thanks.

0 Kudos
1 Reply
KellyGerrow
Esri Frequent Contributor

Hi,

When considering which architecture to use it is helpful to understand what you want to accomplish that you currently can't with your current infrastructure. Most likely, there are benefits to using both ArcGIS Enterprise and ArcGIS Online that you will want to consider. Both technologies are can work together to give you the best of both the SAAS and Enterprise infrastructure. I'd suggest seeing if there are service types or functionality in ArcGIS Enterprise, like geoprocessing, network analysis, dynamic map services that you would like to start using. Also consider if you want to manage your own infrastructure or use the ArcGIS Online Cloud Infrastructure. Both ArcGIS Online and ArcGIS Enterprise have Hosted Feature Services, web maps, configurable apps, tile services, etc. so look into what the differentiation for you is.

While others are weighing in on this question, here are some resources and previous geonet posts that may be helpful (note that some of the posts are old and may refer to capabilities that are now available in both 😞

http://www.esri.com/~/media/files/pdfs/products/arcgis-platform/architecting-the-arcgis-platform 

Are  ArcGIS Online and Portal redundant

Can ArcGIS Online entirely replace ArcGIS Server?

https://community.esri.com/thread/67706 

-Kelly

0 Kudos