I don't know if you'll be doing a lot of this sort of thing, but if so, you should invest the time into downloading, installing, and learning the Geospatial Modelling Environment (spatialecology.com), which has replaced Hawth's Tools.
The particular function that does exactly what you want is isectpolyrst (Intersect Polygon with Raster). It replaces the Thematic Raster Summary of the old Hawth's tools.
Greg